I recently did a bit of spring cleaning, and realized that we have too much stuff! I needed to declutter and get rid of a bunch of things. I didn’t just want to donate everything; I wanted to make a little cash so I decided to consign in Orlando.
My go-to places are usually eBay and Facebook, but they can be such a hassle. You question whether it’s worth it between the fees and shipping. Not to mention that you get a lot of time-wasters who ask many questions only to leave you hanging.
I ended up cleaning out our closets and going through all the clothes, shoes, and purses. Then, I went through our LEGO and Pokémon card collections. All in all, I found some great places in and around Orlando that pay cash for your items.
Consign in Orlando: Kids’ clothes and toys
Once Upon a Child
multiple locations
There should be one close to you with seven locations in and around Orlando. The store I went to was the Waterford Lakes store. I had a good experience and bought new and gently used clothes and toys there. Remember that they don’t take everything you bring and usually ask for specific items/sizes that can change daily/week. It’s best to call them before heading out. Also, go early because I once went 2 hours before closing, and they told me they were not accepting anything else because they were full. They don’t keep anything overnight; you must pick it up the same day. Be sure to bring your driver’s license at pick up so they can confirm your identity and pay you.
Play It Again Sports
multiple locations
Are you looking to get rid of sporting equipment? This might be the place for you. I haven’t been to this yet, but I have heard good things about it. They have one in Winter Springs and one in Altamonte Springs.
Orlando Brick Co.
480 S Ronald Reagan Blvd suite 1000, Longwood, FL 32750
Are you looking to get rid of that pile of LEGO? Orlando Brick Co. is one of the largest building brick toy stores with more LEGO products than you have ever seen in one place! We recently learned about this place and took the kids; it was better than the regular LEGO store! The staff is incredible, and the variety is fantastic — new sets, old sets, already-built sets, mini-figures, and more. We initially went there to get something for the kids but found out they also buy your new/used LEGO items, and you don’t need an appointment.
Big League Cards
920 FL-436, Casselberry, FL 32707
Do you have a bunch of trading cards that you’re looking to sell? Big Leagues is the place for you. They’re located in Casselberry, and they mostly buy Pokemon and Sports cards. The staff is super nice, but they are selective about the cards they buy. Their website states that you need an appointment to sell, but I’ve seen them take walk-ins. Your best bet is to call them to ask!
Consign in Orlando: Designer clothes or Disney merch
Plato’s Closet
multiple locations
They have about eight locations in and around Orlando, and it’s the best place to send in trendy clothes, like the ones teenagers like to wear. They also take in Disney clothing, accessories, and backpacks. I like that they give you an itemized receipt so you know how much you’re getting for each item. I do have to warn you: don’t expect to get much cash from them, but if you’re in a hurry to get rid of items, they’re a good choice. They take some men’s styles, mainly athletic wear.
Style Encore
610 North Alafaya Trail Orlando, FL 32828
This store is located right next to Plato’s Closet, so I went to both on the same day. Whenever they didn’t take items at Plato’s, I took them to Style Encore. That’s when I realized that Style Encore focuses less on trendy and more on classic styles. They recently started accepting men’s clothes.
Gatorlillys
multiple locations
Did someone say, Lilly Pulitzer? Gatorlillys is one of my favorite resale stores, not just because all their boutiques are aesthetically pleasing but because I never leave empty-handed! It defeats the purpose of selling, but you should still take your clothes there because you might have a stronger will than me. With four locations, they mainly take Lilly Pulitzer (clothing and accessories) but also accept Lululemon and Tori Burch sandals. The owner is the one that does the buyout, so if you visit one of their 4 locations and she’s not in, they can still accept it and will call you back when she makes it to the store.
Dechoes
Multiple locations
Are you looking to sell your designer items? Dechoes is the place for you. They take designer, vintage, and modern clothing, shoes, bags, and accessories. They have two locations in Orlando, but you have to make an appointment to sell. You can do it online or via their app. I tried talking a bag to them but did not go through with the sale because their offer was low. But they’re a good option if you’re looking for an easy way to sell.
Designers Seconds
110 N Orlando Ave, Maitland, FL 32751
This place has been on my list for quite some time, but I haven’t been able to go yet, although I have heard good things about it. Their website states that it’s best to call them to check what brand/season they are currently accepting and to make an appointment.
In order to consign in Orlando, you need to have a lot of patience. Consignment don’t always take everything and you need to be strategic about when you go and what you take. But with a little patience, strategic planning, you can make some money instead of just donating.
